Black Friday offers.

See offers
Pepys

Working paper

Institutional Guidance on AI Transcription for Research Interviews: A Survey of 130 Universities in the United States, United Kingdom and Canada

Ankur Shrestha, Pepys, United States · 2026-10-31

Abstract

Researchers routinely upload interview recordings to cloud AI transcription tools, but it is unclear what their institutions tell them to do. We surveyed the public guidance of 130 institutions: 100 US R1 universities drawn at random from 187, 15 of the 24 UK Russell Group members, and all 15 Canadian U15 members. Each institution was coded twice, independently, in a language-model-assisted workflow from saved page text, and disagreements were resolved against the page text. Ninety institutions (69.2%, 95% CI 60.8–76.5) published something that touches AI tools and recordings or transcription, but only 73 (56.2%) gave transcription-specific guidance; 40 (30.8%) had none we could find. Sixty-one institutions name at least one tool as approved or prohibited. Zoom's AI features are approved at 41 institutions and Microsoft Teams at 20, while stand-alone meeting bots are barred: Read.ai at 17, Fireflies.ai at 11 and Otter.ai at 20, yet Otter.ai is also approved at 5. Only 25.6% of institutions with guidance say researchers must disclose AI transcription in the ethics protocol, and 36.7% publish no date. Inter-coder agreement was high on whether guidance exists (κ = 0.89) and moderate on stance (κ = 0.68). Institutions give researchers different answers about the same products, and much of the guidance is drawn from IT pages on meetings rather than from ethics offices.

What transcription software do universities allow?

It depends on the university. Policies vary, and the same tool can be approved at some institutions and prohibited at others. In the public guidance of 130 large research universities, collected on 30 September 2026, the tools most often approved were platforms the institution already licenses, such as Zoom's AI features (approved at 41) and Microsoft Teams (20), while stand-alone meeting bots were the tools most often barred. Otter.ai was prohibited at 20 institutions and approved at 5.

Sixty-one of the 130 institutions name at least one tool as approved or prohibited, and 40 had no guidance we could find. Counts are institutions, not mentions, and a tool can be approved at one institution and prohibited at another.

Selected rows from Table 2 of the paper: tools named by status across institutions
Tool familyInstitutions approvingInstitutions prohibiting
Zoom (AI Companion and built-in transcription)411
Microsoft Teams (including Teams Premium)200
Microsoft 365 (Word Transcribe, Copilot, Stream)131
Whisper-based or local tools121
Rev63
Otter.ai520
Read.ai017
Fireflies.ai111

The sample covers large research universities in the United States, United Kingdom and Canada, and pages change, so check your own ethics office or IRB before you upload research recordings; a missing rule is a question to ask, not a permission. No institution in the sample names Pepys, and the study did not test any vendor's product.

Where to find it

Putting it into practice

Cite

@misc{shrestha2026institutional,
  author       = {Shrestha, Ankur},
  title        = {Institutional Guidance on AI Transcription for Research Interviews: A Survey of 130 Universities in the United States, United Kingdom and Canada},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {SSRN preprint, abstract\_id 7685681},
  doi          = {10.5281/zenodo.23846598},
  url          = {https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7685681}
}

RIS

TY  - RPRT
AU  - Shrestha, Ankur
TI  - Institutional Guidance on AI Transcription for Research Interviews: A Survey of 130 Universities in the United States, United Kingdom and Canada
PY  - 2026
DA  - 2026/10/31
PB  - SSRN
ET  - 1.0
UR  - https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7685681
DO  - 10.5281/zenodo.23846598
N1  - Dataset: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23846481
KW  - AI transcription
KW  - research ethics
KW  - institutional review boards
KW  - data governance
KW  - qualitative research
KW  - document analysis
AB  - Researchers routinely upload interview recordings to cloud AI transcription tools, but it is unclear what their institutions tell them to do. We surveyed the public guidance of 130 institutions: 100 US R1 universities drawn at random from 187, 15 of the 24 UK Russell Group members, and all 15 Canadian U15 members. Each institution was coded twice, independently, in a language-model-assisted workflow from saved page text, and disagreements were resolved against the page text. Ninety institutions (69.2%, 95% CI 60.8–76.5) published something that touches AI tools and recordings or transcription, but only 73 (56.2%) gave transcription-specific guidance; 40 (30.8%) had none we could find. Sixty-one institutions name at least one tool as approved or prohibited. Zoom's AI features are approved at 41 institutions and Microsoft Teams at 20, while stand-alone meeting bots are barred: Read.ai at 17, Fireflies.ai at 11 and Otter.ai at 20, yet Otter.ai is also approved at 5. Only 25.6% of institutions with guidance say researchers must disclose AI transcription in the ethics protocol, and 36.7% publish no date. Inter-coder agreement was high on whether guidance exists (κ = 0.89) and moderate on stance (κ = 0.68). Institutions give researchers different answers about the same products, and much of the guidance is drawn from IT pages on meetings rather than from ethics offices.
ER  - 

Version history